Medigap Plan I is a discontinued plan, not one of the current standardized plans sold to new applicants. If you already hold an older Plan I policy, you can generally keep it. Do not confuse the letter I with a policy number or assume it describes Medicare Advantage.

What establishes your benefits?
Your issued policy, outline of coverage and amendments establish the terms. Current plan charts omit Plan I because it is no longer sold; the omission does not cancel an existing policy. Nor does it authorize a seller to market a newly available Plan I.
| Question for your insurer | Document to request |
|---|---|
| Is my coverage active? | Written current policy status and paid-through information. |
| Which costs does it supplement? | The original benefit schedule with applicable amendments. |
| What happens abroad? | Foreign travel emergency provisions and remaining lifetime benefit. |
| Has the premium changed? | Renewal or rate-change notice and payment instructions. |
Medicare identifies older Plan I as including limited foreign travel emergency coverage. Confirm its deductible, payment percentage, timing conditions and lifetime limit from the actual contract before a trip.
Review a replacement before canceling
A new policy can differ from your older one. Compare covered benefits and annual costs, and check whether medical underwriting applies. Being able to renew an existing policy does not mean every insurer must accept a replacement application.
The fall Medicare enrollment period does not automatically provide Medigap guaranteed issue rights. Your state may offer additional protections. Ask the state insurance department or SHIP to help identify the rule that applies to your circumstances.
Keep a written record
- Confirm the new insurer’s acceptance and effective date.
- Review the applicable 30-day free-look and overlapping premiums.
- Follow cancellation instructions only after deciding to keep the replacement.
- Retain both benefit summaries and all notices.
Do not assume you can return to a discontinued policy after canceling it.
Related coverage questions
- What Is Medigap? Benefits, Costs and Enrollment
- How to Compare Medigap Policies
- Medigap Comparison Chart: Benefits and 2026 Cost Limits