Skip to content
Home INFORMATION AT YOUR PACE

Medicare Advantage Star Ratings: How to Use Them When Comparing Plans

Understand Medicare’s quality ratings, why an unrated plan is different from a low-rated plan, and what to check alongside the stars.

Explore this page

Medicare Star Ratings summarize health and prescription coverage quality and performance on a scale from one to five. They can help narrow a comparison, but a higher rating does not establish that a plan covers your doctors or has the lowest cost for your care.

Older couple holding hands on a park bench

Read the correct rating

Match the rating year and contract to the plan you are considering. An insurer can offer multiple contracts with different results. Ratings change, so an old five-star advertisement is not proof of the current score.

CMS publishes annual technical notes explaining the measures and calculation method. A blank result may mean insufficient data or a plan that is too new to rate. It is not automatically a zero-star result.

Compare quality with practical fit

Check Why it matters
Star rating Provides quality and performance context.
Doctors and hospitals Your actual locations must participate as required.
Total expenses Premiums, deductibles and copayments affect your budget.
Coverage rules Referrals and authorization can affect access.

Review the Summary of Benefits and Evidence of Coverage. A strong overall score does not remove exclusions, annual benefit limits or the need for approval of certain services.

The five-star enrollment opportunity

If an eligible five-star plan is offered in your area, Medicare permits a special switch once between December 8 and November 30 of the following year. Confirm that you qualify and understand what happens to your existing coverage.

Switching to a plan without Part D can leave a gap in prescription coverage. The star rating alone should not determine that decision.

Make a recorded comparison

Save the full plan identifier, benefit year, provider confirmations and expected costs. Check the current rating in Medicare's plan comparison tool and use CMS's technical notes if you need to understand how a particular measure was calculated.

Related coverage questions

Official sources

YOUR NEXT STEP STARTS HERE

Let’s figure it out together.

Our Agents

Compare your plan options

SunFire · Secure plan comparison
Open in a new tab ↗

Loading SunFire… If it takes a moment, you can open it in a new tab.