Navigating Medicare Supplement Plans (Medigap) in 2025 might feel like trying to pick between chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin cookies – both are good but one might suit you better than the other depending on what you want out of the deal. Anthem and UnitedHealthcare are two of the top insurers in the Medicare Supplement market and each one brings a unique set of benefits and maybe a few quirks to the table. So which one’s right for you? Let’s dive into the details with a little help from Henry Beltran owner of Medicare Advisors Insurance Group LLC.
“Every Medicare Supplement plan has its charm but the best one really depends on what works for your health needs your budget and well your personal taste” – Henry Beltran
Overview of Anthem Medicare Supplement Plans
Anthem has been around for a while and when it comes to Medicare Supplement plans they tend to keep things straightforward. With Anthem you can expect access to a broad network of doctors a well-developed support system and plans that cover your basic Medicare gaps without too many frills.
Key Benefits of Anthem
- Wide network: Anthem offers a massive list of in-network doctors making it ideal for folks who want flexibility in their provider options.
- Efficient Claims Process: Anthem’s claims processing is generally fast which can save you the headache of waiting on reimbursements for out-of-pocket expenses.
- Well-established reputation: Anthem is a trusted brand in the insurance world so if stability and trust matter it’s a solid choice.
Potential Drawbacks of Anthem
- Slightly Higher Premiums: Anthem’s rates can be a bit higher for some Medigap plans. Think of it like ordering avocado toast – you’re paying a premium for the name and trust but it’s not always budget-friendly.
- Customer Service: While Anthem tries its best their customer service can sometimes leave folks feeling a bit like they’re on hold forever. If you’re not a fan of long wait times this could be a dealbreaker.
Find Medicare Plans in 3 Easy Steps
We can help get up to $0 monthly premium Medicare plans
Overview of UnitedHealthcare Medicare Supplement Plans
UnitedHealthcare (UHC) backed by the AARP brand is known for its Medigap options. UHC’s plans tend to appeal to folks who want to keep their healthcare simple and predictable with a provider that has its fingers in a lot of healthcare pies.
Key Benefits of UnitedHealthcare
- Competitive Pricing: UHC often offers lower premiums especially in their popular Medigap plans making it a favorite for budget-conscious seniors.
- Household Discount: They even offer a nifty household discount if both you and your spouse enroll in a Medigap plan.
- User-Friendly Tech: UHC offers mobile app support which might be a win for tech-savvy users wanting to manage things on the go.
Potential Drawbacks of UnitedHealthcare
- Doctor Network: UHC’s network isn’t always as expansive as Anthem’s so your favorite doctor may not be covered. Imagine picking out a donut only to find out it’s actually celery – UHC’s network limitations could leave you with some surprises.
- Prescription Drug Exclusions: UHC’s Medigap plans don’t include prescription drug coverage so you’ll need to get a separate Part D plan to cover those meds. Henry Beltran puts it best “It’s like buying a car without the tires sure you can get it on the road but you’re not getting the full experience.”
Find Medicare Plans in 3 Easy Steps
We can help get up to $0 monthly premium Medicare plans
Comparing Anthem and UnitedHealthcare Plans in 2025
So which one is right for you? Let’s break it down by the factors that matter most.
Cost
Anthem’s premiums are often a little higher but they come with the peace of mind of a wide network and fast claims service. UHC tends to have a lower premium so if saving money is key UHC could be the winner here.
Provider Access
If having the freedom to choose almost any doctor is top of your list Anthem might be the way to go. UnitedHealthcare’s network can be a bit more restrictive – something to keep in mind if you’re particular about your providers.
Customer Service
If you’re not a fan of long hold times well… neither option is perfect. But if you’re okay with the occasional wait UHC’s app support can help streamline a lot of basic customer service tasks.
Extra Perks
UnitedHealthcare has household discounts that could help you save but Anthem’s seamless claims process might be worth a few extra bucks especially if you don’t want to deal with red tape every time you need coverage.
Important Things to Consider in 2025
When it comes to Medicare Supplement Plans one size doesn’t fit all. Here are a few points you should really consider:
- Your Doctor’s Network: Is your primary care physician in-network for the plan you’re considering?
- Prescription Coverage: Neither Anthem nor UHC includes Part D coverage in their Medigap plans – you’ll have to buy this separately.
- Plan G vs. Plan N: Plan G offers comprehensive coverage but costs more while Plan N has lower premiums but you’ll have some copays. Make sure you know what each plan includes.
- Cost Predictability: Some people prefer to pay a bit more each month and avoid surprise costs. Others don’t mind a copay now and then to keep premiums low.
Henry Beltran’s Recommendation for 2025
“For most people Plan G is the best option for comprehensive coverage and peace of mind. But if budget is a priority you might want to look into Plan N or even compare some of the high-deductible options if you don’t mind a little risk” – Henry Beltran
Henry suggests that while UnitedHealthcare might win on price for most folks Anthem’s flexibility with doctors and efficient claims process makes it worth the investment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Difference Between Anthem and UnitedHealthcare?
Anthem generally has a larger network and a reputation for fast claims service but costs a bit more. UHC is usually more affordable but their network can be limited and you’ll need a separate Part D plan for prescriptions.
Do Both Anthem and UnitedHealthcare Offer Medicare Supplement Plans in Every State?
No Anthem and UnitedHealthcare vary in availability by state. Make sure you check with your advisor or directly with the providers to confirm coverage in your state.
Which Plan Should I Choose?
There’s no “best” option because the right plan depends on your healthcare needs and budget. A Medicare advisor like Henry Beltran can help you weigh your choices and pick the best fit.
Find Medicare Plans in 3 Easy Steps
We can help get up to $0 monthly premium Medicare plans
Bottom Line
When it comes to choosing between Anthem and UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Supplement plans it’s all about what you value most – flexibility or cost savings. Anthem is great for those who want the freedom to choose almost any doctor without worrying about networks and UnitedHealthcare makes sense for those who prioritize affordability and don’t mind sticking to a smaller network.
To wrap it up as Henry Beltran puts it “There’s no one-size-fits-all solution to Medicare supplements. If you want more flexibility go with Anthem. If saving a few bucks is your goal UnitedHealthcare might just be your new best friend.”
In the end whether you go for the “antique” appeal of Anthem or the “united” vibe of UHC you’re sure to find a plan that keeps you covered where it counts.
