A useful Medicare coverage analysis compares how each option would cover your own care. The worksheet below is a planning tool, not an eligibility decision, a price quote or a substitute for a plan's current documents.

Begin with your current arrangement
Record whether you have Original Medicare or Medicare Advantage, any supplemental coverage, your county and the coverage year. Do not compare a current plan against an old brochure or combine benefits from two different products.
| Item to record | Current coverage | Proposed coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Plan name, identifiers and year | Write exact details. | Write exact details. |
| Doctors and hospitals | Confirm participation. | Confirm each location. |
| Monthly premiums | Include Medicare and other policy premiums. | Include every required premium. |
| Medical costs | List deductible and expected visit or hospital costs. | Use the same expected services. |
| Spending protection | Identify applicable limits or supplemental payments. | Note what the limit excludes. |
| Additional coverage | Record included and separately purchased benefits. | Check eligibility, limits and providers. |
Compare equivalent arrangements
Medigap supplements certain Original Medicare expenses. It cannot pay Medicare Advantage copayments. Original Medicare generally has no annual out-of-pocket limit; Medicare Advantage has a limit for covered medical services. Neither fact tells you the total cost without reviewing the rest of your coverage.
Test the comparison against practical situations
- Your usual specialist appointment.
- A planned procedure with separate professional and facility bills.
- Routine care while away from home.
- A service that the medical benefit excludes.
Ask who pays, which providers can be used and whether authorization is needed. Keep unanswered items separate from confirmed benefits.
Before acting on the worksheet
Confirm enrollment rights, the start date and effects on employer or union coverage. Verify Medigap purchase rights separately. Keep written answers or call reference numbers and never cancel existing coverage solely because an advertisement looks less expensive.
Related coverage questions
- How to Compare Medicare Advantage Plans: A Practical Worksheet
- How to Compare Medigap Policies
- How to Verify Your Medicare Coverage and Plan Enrollment