Do not cancel your current Medigap policy just because another premium looks lower. Outside protected enrollment situations, you may not have a federal right to buy a replacement. State rules can provide additional protections.

First identify your reason
Are you seeking lower premiums, different benefits or a different insurer? Write down the specific problem. Compare the proposed policy's benefits and possible out-of-pocket costs with the policy you already own, not just the monthly bill.
A safer sequence
- Ask whether an open enrollment or guaranteed-issue right applies.
- Keep notices showing when prior coverage ends and why.
- Get a complete quote and answer application questions accurately.
- Wait for a written decision and confirm the start date.
- Review applicable free-look rights and cancellation instructions before ending the old policy.
Ask about overlap and waiting periods
There may be a period when you pay both premiums while reviewing a new policy. Ask the insurer how to use any free-look period and whether a waiting period for pre-existing conditions applies. Keep written answers with your records.
Leaving Medicare Advantage?
Your opportunity to leave that plan and your right to buy Medigap are separate questions. Confirm both before changing. A plan-election window by itself does not guarantee a Medigap insurer will accept you.
For rights that depend on your state or a specific event, use your State Insurance Department or SHIP for independent assistance. Avoid a coverage gap while you gather answers.
Continue with a related question
- Your Medigap Open Enrollment Period
- Changing Medicare Coverage Without Losing Track
- How to Compare Medigap Policies